Moto-E paddock on fire

Discussion in 'General' started by Phl218, Mar 14, 2019.

  1. Venom51

    Venom51 John Deere Equipment Expert

    Well just like Formula E it's going to be a dumpster fire of entertainment anyway, This just happened without the dumpster.
     
    BigBird and Mot Okstef like this.
  2. knedragon29

    knedragon29 Well-Known Member

    They just revised the schedule and new class name is Moto-F
     
    Inst Tech likes this.
  3. Trunxgp1224

    Trunxgp1224 Well-Known Member

    Foam works better but water will still get the job done. On both EVs there's an easily accessible cut off that kills the high voltage power from the car and keeps any high voltage things from being energized. If the HV battery cells are compromised and you have a run away the only way out is the batteries to discharge, that will either be a conventional electrical discharge or it'll runaway and catch fire.

    https://www.tesla.com/sites/default...16_Models_S_Emergency_Responders_Guide_en.pdf

    Commifornia is requiring solar panel installation on all new homes come 1/1/2020. It's not the same as retrofitting the systems and because it's designed into the home it will have lower costs, you'll also have lower panel cost as a factor of economies of scale. I can see both sides of the coin, it takes away the option from the homeowner but it's also pretty much guaranteed to pay itself off in almost every situation and reduces stress on the grid that people seem to complain about in that state. There are also ways around installing them on the individual home, things like community shared energy options. It removes the individual mandate and lets the developer determine how to implement the requirements.
     
    Last edited: Mar 14, 2019
    BigBird likes this.
  4. Trunxgp1224

    Trunxgp1224 Well-Known Member

    They probably have insurance on them for things like fire, flood, theft, damage and whatever else can happen off the race track.
     
  5. Mot Okstef

    Mot Okstef Well-Known Member

    Serious question. What if the entire car is completely engulfed in flames? How do you get to the cutoff?
     
  6. Trunxgp1224

    Trunxgp1224 Well-Known Member

    If you're at that point whoever is in the car is fucked at that point. The purpose of the cut off isn't to prevent a fire it's to protect the occupants and first responders from getting shocked by the high voltage DC battery 350 or 400v depending on model. If you cut the safety loop it contains the power in the battery and de-energizes things like the motor(s), charger(s), charger port, heater, DC-DC inverter, etc. All of these items run directly on 350/400v while everything else in the car operates off of normal 12v like a typical car. All the cut off does is remove high voltage power from those things so firefighters have less concern about getting shocked by anything trying to get someone out, it has nothing to do with stopping or preventing a fire from the main battery.
     
    BigBird, Sabre699 and Mot Okstef like this.
  7. Mot Okstef

    Mot Okstef Well-Known Member

    Cool. Thanks for the explanation. Makes sense. I wasn't aware you could be shocked by one. :eek:

    Obviously I know nothing about hybrid/electric cars. :D
     
  8. R Acree

    R Acree WTF

    You're in luck, Trunx knows everything.:D
     
    scottn, brex and Mot Okstef like this.
  9. bored&stroked

    bored&stroked Disclaimer: Can't spell

    Just like a double rainbow, I'm not sure what this means.
     
    Bruce likes this.
  10. Mot Okstef

    Mot Okstef Well-Known Member

    :crackup:
     
  11. ChemGuy

    ChemGuy Harden The F%@# Up!

    Pic of charger involved...

    [​IMG]
     
  12. gixxernaut

    gixxernaut Hold my beer & watch this

    Perhaps not if they went with eInsurance. :crackup:
     
  13. Mongo

    Mongo Sacko

    Could be the tech but it could be as simple as the power they ran to the tent was done wrong or badly. On that note I was wondering where they get the juice, from the track or do they need a huge genset to charge everything?
     
  14. Mongo

    Mongo Sacko

    Batteries versus a power plant. The juice isn't the issue it's the battery packs.
     
  15. zrx12man

    zrx12man Captain Amazing

    Fake news:

    From this study:
    http://www.fraunhofer.jp/content/da...1016_ISE_Recent_Facts_about_PV_in_Germany.pdf

    "Based on investigations to date, all of the claims stating that the fire brigade could not extinguish a house fire due to the PV system have been found to be false.”
     
  16. Phl218

    Phl218 Lemme ask my wife

  17. zrx12man

    zrx12man Captain Amazing

    So, anecdotes } data. Got it ;)
     
  18. Venom51

    Venom51 John Deere Equipment Expert

    Let's be honest. The pit fire was far more exciting than the racing would be.
     
    Mot Okstef and zrx12man like this.
  19. zrx12man

    zrx12man Captain Amazing

    The actual situation seems more nuanced than what you said, of course the presence of PV panels on a rooftop changes the firefighting equation and adds some hazards that are not present otherwise. Given the proliferation of rooftop PV panels in Germany particularly, it's simply not true that firefighters there as a general policy simply refuse to combat fires in these structures and just "let them burn". That's ridiculous.
     
  20. elvee

    elvee Well-Known Member

    I would bet that all the chargers would fit into a decent sized three phase disconnect. 200 amps theee phase maybe? Less than what you need to out on even a small concert.
     

Share This Page