Who's the best QB of all time?

Yeah, four. I messed that up as I meant he had three more than Young's one (as a starter - he has two as a backup to Montana). Definitely has him beat in SB wins.
Man this site sucks ass at night, slower than 90s porn on a 56k modem.

 

The fact that a German only knows Joe Montana when it comes to quarterbacks says it all. Montana.

 

Joe Pisarcik

 

Jackie Parker. Ol' Spaghetti Legs.

 

Shane Falco

 

uncle rico

 

Yep! He could throw a pig skin a Quarter Mile ... If the coach would have put him in the 4 th quarter they would have won the State Championship! He'd be making Millions .

 

When he's done, it might be Russell Wilson.

Brady.

 

Brady... cause he is still not done yet breaking records

 

That guy had a gun for an arm.

I'd have to go with Johnny Utah.

 

If it's just SB rings, then you got to include Terry Bradshaw...he did it first.....then again, his team might have had something to do with it. I think I'd have to give it to Peyton, different teams, different eras, it puts more of the credit to him. Put Brady in the Colts organization and he's just another QB...good but not great.
It's kinda like Rossi and Stoner...both managed to win with different bikes.

 

Manning, Montana, Bradshaw have always been my favorites. Manning is hard to argue against, Favre probably second for all time. Newton, Brady are both over rated at this point.

Wait, did someone say Desaun Watson up there?

 

Johnny Manziel

 

Al Bundy

 

Brady has won it with the least talented teams, IMHO. Brady...

 

Utah got hurt and never played pro, he had a bad knee.

 

Joe Namath, the only QB with the cajones big enough to GUARANTEE a Super Bowl win and the talent to go back it up. He may only have one, but doing it like he did, you only need one. J-E-T-S Jets, Jets, Jets fans are STILL waiting for him to walk back through the door.

 

Y.A. Tittle

• 7× Pro Bowl (1953, 1954, 1957, 1959, 1961–1963)
• 3× AP First-team All-Pro (1957, 1962, 1963)
• 4× UPI First-Team All-Pro (1957, 1961–1963)
• 1957 NFL MVP (UPI)
• 1961 NFL MVP (NEA)
• 1962 NFL MVP (NEA, UPI, SN)
• 1963 NFL MVP (AP, NEA, SN)
• First to throw 30 touchdowns in consecutive seasons
• Threw seven touchdowns in one game

Stats From Wikipedia

 

Otto Graham

 

Gordie Howe