Internet Tech: speed test confusion

Discussion in 'General' started by duggram, Dec 6, 2018.

  1. speedluvn

    speedluvn On a Quest For Speed

    Cut the cord! :Poke:
     
  2. I'm with Stupid

    I'm with Stupid Sentimental Visigoth

    In my last house in the US I had had TDS FTTP for the six years before I moved. It was awesome - best home ISP I've had. So, for a gauge on RAS, I don't think you need to worry.

    If the only service you're having problems with is Sling, the issue could be on their end, or it could be a routing/node problem between you and them.

    As others have noted, "speedtest" websites are generally useless, and anyway, 13mbps is sufficient to stream all but the most demanding media, IF you don't have other connection issues. Bandwidth, line quality, and lack of routing issues are more important for video streaming than circuit bit rate ("speed"). There are a number of tests that will tell you if you have problems in these areas (traceroute, ping tests, jitter measurements, etc.), but you have to know how to judge the results.

    The first thing anyone knowledgeable is going to tell you, and I'm going to tell you this too - don't use Wifi if you want reliable streaming. Anyone with troubleshooting skills will tell you that you need to eliminate the Wifi variable if you want to successfully troubleshoot connection problems.
     
    BigBird likes this.
  3. Jed

    Jed mellifluous

    Would the DNS server impact the routing to the actual site or just resolve the address and pass it along? For example my router is using a Comcast DNS server. If I change to Open DNS do I avoid traffic restrictions set by ISP?
     
  4. BigBird

    BigBird blah

    no.
     
  5. PistolPete

    PistolPete Gone sailing...

    No cord! I’m 5 miles by sea from the antenna, it’s cellular. I can pay for up to 6 mbps, but it’s salty...
     
  6. I'm with Stupid

    I'm with Stupid Sentimental Visigoth

    You have a modem, not an Optical Network Terminal (ONT)? If so, something to keep in mind:

    FTTP (Fiber To The Premises) uses an ONT, and FTTP (even PON) typical delivers at, or close to, advertised speed and bandwidth. FTTN/FTTC (Fiber To The Node/Fiber To The Curb) typically uses VDSL with a VDSL modem. VDSL frequently does not deliver advertised speed and bandwidth. Performance is based on your distance from the Node or Curb connection.

    Here in the Fatherland I had a choice between cable-based internet and FTTN VDSL. I absolutely despise cable internet, especially in densely populated areas where other bandwidth-sucking pigs are competing with my bandwidth sucking, but the closest Fiber Node is too far away to give me the bandwidth I need, and most of my usage is during the day when everyone else in my neighborhood is gone, so I went with cable.

    Nevertheless, if the VDSL link is properly set up, you should expect consistently better performance than you would get over a cellular data network. If you are on FTTN VDSL from TDS, you should ask them what level of real-world performance you can expect based on your distance from the node. You might need to ask the regional engineer at your local TDS office, instead of the people on the phone support line, as they probably won't have any idea.

    And one more time - don't use wireless for streaming video! Wireless is half-duplex, and is easily interfered with. You can get major performance degradation just by someone in your house using a cordless phone, or a neighbor using a baby monitor, or any number of other interference points.
     
    BigBird likes this.
  7. _indy

    _indy Well-Known Member

    When things are working well. I get identical results from https://www.speakeasy.net/speedtest/ compared to the Comcast test results.
    Yes in many cases the Comcast show some great numbers but everything else sucks.
    When I talk with support and give results from tracert to several sites they start checking.
    I'm paying for 75 mb,, just tested and got "12/6/2018 3:23:32 PM 184.25 Mbps download 11.97 Mbps upload
     
  8. I'm with Stupid

    I'm with Stupid Sentimental Visigoth

    Comcast is the worst ISP I've ever encountered. Everything about them sucks. I could tell stories for days. I'd suffer with a 3mbps DSL link before I ever gave Comcast another dime.
     
  9. BigBird

    BigBird blah

    Before I switched to Verizon from optimum at the time, the speed test would come back at like 2-3 mbps, or even less during peak times, but be ok after peak, which is most cable network systems.

    I said I'm supposed to be getting 50 mbps, and the customer service agent was like we said UP to 50 mbps. I was like WTF, and they were like for $20 or $30 we can get you to a higher minimum. I was like nah bruh, imme get that Old Ma Bell joint.

    Been happy every since, well except the price, but I have no issues with it.
     
  10. duggram

    duggram Well-Known Member

    I'll get back here this evening to read all the replies in detail. I'm burning daylight now. But I did call SlingTV and they suggested the issue was the Roku device I use and sure enough Roku devices can have buffering issues. So I'm trying an old Apple TV now.
     
  11. Tristan

    Tristan Well-Known Member

    Speed tests are the bane of my existence (well, one of them). Lots of good responses above, I'll just add: don't even think about using IE browser for testing, use Chrome or Firefox.
     
  12. Chango

    Chango The GOAT is my hero.

    My first thought upon reading this is the difference between Mbps and MBps. Since 1B=8b, if the one speed test was giving results in MegaBytes and the others were in Megabits, that would account for the difference as 100 Mb is 12.5 MB, which would round up to 13.

    Or maybe I'm just making shit up. Again.
     
  13. Jedb

    Jedb Professional Novice :-)

    At those speeds, a crayon map is about all you'll be able to get accomplished.
     
  14. I'm with Stupid

    I'm with Stupid Sentimental Visigoth

    Man, I will never forget when I got my first 256k ISDN link at home. It was awesome - a huge upgrade from a 56k dial-up modem. It no longer took 6 hours and multiple retries to download a 30-second low-res porn clip. It downloaded in one try, and only took about 90 minutes! Bliss!
     
    BigBird and speedluvn like this.
  15. CRA_Fizzer

    CRA_Fizzer Honking at putter!

    You guys say don't use wireless but how can you when a Firestick, for example, is wireless...

    Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk
     
  16. Jedb

    Jedb Professional Novice :-)

    Firestick runs on wireless from a local (wired) modem.

    Fixed Wireless is a completely different thing.
     
  17. thrak410

    thrak410 My member is well known

    Get the Ethernet adapter and wire it up
     
  18. BigBird

    BigBird blah

Share This Page