1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Traeger, Big Green Egg, ol' standard Weber, or somethin else?

Discussion in 'General' started by tophyr, May 18, 2024.

Tags:
  1. Spang308

    Spang308 Well-Known Member

    Screenshot_20250730_120247_Gallery.jpg
    This is delicious on pork bbq. Throw pulled pork on a roll, squirt this all over it and top it off with coleslaw.

    Slaw:
    1 bag shredded slaw, Dole Southern preferred
    1/2 cup Dukes mayo
    4 Tbs sugar
    1 1/2 Tbs lemon juice
    1 Tbs vinegar
    1 Tbs honey
    1 tspn celery seed
    1/2 tspn pepper
     
    PatricksDad and ducnut like this.
  2. wsmc42

    wsmc42 Well-Known Member

    I almost went looking for this thread back around 4th of July. My 9 or 10 year old Traeger has been acting up more and more. I figured it was a good time to buy a new grill. I looked at Traeger, Pit Boss and Recteq. I ended up going with the Recteq Deck Boss. The thing is built like a tank. The solid feel, stainless steel drum and stainless grates helped me decide on spending the extra dough compared to the others. And I have to add, customer service is great. Nice to get an actual person on the phone that is right here in the US of A.

    So far, I have to say it cooks better than my old Traeger. It holds temp much better and gives more smoke flavor. So far , rib eyes, ribs and meat loaf have all come out as good or better than on my old grill.
     
    pjzocc and ducnut like this.
  3. ducnut

    ducnut Well-Known Member

    Without starting another thread:

    Single guy who only cooks for himself, first pellet, don’t have all day to mess with it. Currently, have a Weber Go-Anywhere LP camp grille and Weber 36” griddle. Looking to step up to a smoker, for flavor.

    Looking at these, in this order:
    1.) Recteq RT-B380X. Looks like the quick heat advantages of an Egg, along with smoking ability. WiFi. $700.
    2.) Recteq Patio Legend 400. Less expensive. More traditional. $650.
    3.) Recteq RT-B380. Basic version of the “X” model. No WiFi. $450.
    4.) Traeger Pro Series 22. No WiFi. Locally available. $450.

    Thoughts?
     
  4. PatricksDad

    PatricksDad Won’t die a blob

    Master built should be on your list
     
    ducnut likes this.
  5. Steak Travis

    Steak Travis Well-Known Member

    Don’t get a small one. I was thinking I could get away with something small but I’m glad every time that I got the regular size.

    has anyone done Biltong? Got a new friend in class from SA and he brought some his wife made. I want to try to steal the recipe but not sure I’ll get it. May try it soon, it was great
     
    ducnut likes this.
  6. tony 340

    tony 340 Well-Known Member

    Always wanted to try biltong but never dedicated time to it
     
    PatricksDad likes this.
  7. ChemGuy

    ChemGuy Harden The F%@# Up!

    I lived in ATL with an SA guy. He made it all the time just marinade and hang dry in a vented box with a fan and light bulb for some heat for several days.
     
  8. ducnut

    ducnut Well-Known Member

    Confusing number of offerings. What models should I be looking at, for basic stuff, like sausage, brauts, dogs, etc?
     
  9. PatricksDad

    PatricksDad Won’t die a blob

    For that stuff, get a Weber and a charcoal chimney to get you hot coals in 19 mins. ReqTec gets good reviews for grilling stuff. I use my Masterbuilt for low temp like smoking and super high-temp stuff like pizza.
     
    ducnut likes this.
  10. Inst Tech

    Inst Tech ain't no half steppin

  11. Mechdziner714

    Mechdziner714 More Gas Less Brakes

    ducnut likes this.
  12. beechkingd

    beechkingd Well-Known Member

    Get one with Wifi. I have a Traeger pro 575. The wifi/app is the best part of it. You can monitor and adjust the temp from anywhere. Even shut it down when it hits the target temp from the other side of town. It doesn't smoke nearly as well as an offset with lump charcoal, but the ease of use makes it so I actually use it.
     
    ducnut likes this.
  13. PatricksDad

    PatricksDad Won’t die a blob

    This is where the Masterbuilt shines. It has a gravity feed, just using lump and hardwood, so it operates just like a pellet with a fan controller to keep temp.
     
  14. ducnut

    ducnut Well-Known Member

  15. pjzocc

    pjzocc Well-Known Member

    Got the Dualfire 1200 back in May. I like the 2nd smaller side for searing and high heat but can also use for smaller quantity cooks. Recteq makes a helluva nice product.
     
    wsmc42 and ducnut like this.
  16. Steak Travis

    Steak Travis Well-Known Member

    First batch of biltong going. Already ate the smaller bits. I cut these a lil thick but my second batch is cut better and I'll put them on the rack tomorrow. I know humans have been drying meat for a year or two but I can't believe with some salt and seasoning and air flow you can just leave meat out and it's fine. No more buying jerky for me.

    IMG_1174.jpeg
     
    PatricksDad likes this.

Share This Page